This is only available for pickup or local delivery. Please note that the final price for any fractional item will be determined by the exact weight of the cut piece at the time of fulfillment.
Multiple award-winning English-style Clothbound Cheddar made from pasteurized, local Jersey cows milk and aged 16-18 months.
This beautiful cheddar has a natural sweet and tangy sharpness with a savory, earthy finish that keeps giving long after you have taken your last bite.
*2026 American Cheese Society First Place, 3rd Place for Reserve Street Ched
*2026 International Cheese & Dairy Awards Gold Medal
*2026 Los Angeles International Dairy Competition Best of Class Gold Medal
*2025 World Cheese Awards Silver (3 Silvers - 11 Month Aged, 18 Month Aged, 24 Month Aged)
*2025 International Cheese & Dairy Awards Gold Medal, US Dairy Council Best USA Trophy
*2025 American Cheese Society Bronze Medal
*2025 Ohio State Fair Second Place Aged Cheddar
*2024 World Cheese Awards Bronze
*2024 International Cheese and Dairy Awards Gold Medals (3) for Mild, Mature & Extra Mature/Vintage Cheddar, ICDA Trophy - Champion Americas Cheese, US Dairy Council Trophy
*2024 American Cheese Society Gold Medal
*2023 World Cheese Awards Bronze
*2022 American Cheese Society Silver Medal
*2023, 2022, 2021 Ohio State Fair Cheese Competition Reserve Grand Champion & First Place Aged Cheddar
