93 Wine Enthusiast

"Legendary vintner Dick Peterson made this rosé from 100% Pinot Noir grown at his vineyard in Yountville. It's light, crisp and elegant, with intricately layered flavors of strawberries, raspberries, yeast, brioche and vanilla. The mousse is very fine, the finish long and complex. Even at the age of nine years, it's nowhere near ready. Try after 2019."

92 Wine Spectator

"Makes a bold statement, with floral strawberry and almond brioche aromas, offering full-bodied yet balanced citrus, graham cracker and cinnamon flavors. Drink now. 242 cases made. — TF"

90 Antonio Galloni - Vinous

"The 2004 Brut Rosé Richard G. Peterson is soft and silky throughout, with delicate fruit and an understated, feminine personality. Drink this pretty, pale-colored Rosé over the next handful of years. Stylistically, the 2004 is attractive, but a bit slender."