Pies n' Wines: How to Drink Wine with Your Pie and Get Away With It

Posted November 16, 2015

WineLibrary Staff


Daily wine deals emailed to your inbox.

Now that you know what to drink with your side-dishes, it’s time to move onto everybody’s favorite part of Thanksgiving dinner: the pies. Whether you’re grabbing a pre-made pumpkin pie, or simmering down berries yourself for a homemade masterpiece, wine is the perfect compliment for your tastiest of pastries:

Apple pie: 2012 Bello Family Chardonnay

This Chardonnay was practically made to go with apple pie. It’s a rich, lemon-curd-with-vanilla-icing kind of affair. It benefits from a responsible use of oak, but, as with the pie, the fruit here is the star. As you enjoy the soft, gently spiced apples, and the mildly savory crust, a sip of the Bello will not only hold up, but contribute a palate-cleansing acidity. This is a magnificent pairing. Seek it out!

Blueberry pie: 2013 V Mitolo Waveform Cabernet Sauvignon Mclaren Vale

Cabernet Sauvignon can exhibit a whole range of different fruit flavors, but the Waveform comes in solidly on the blue/black side of the spectrum, which is perfect to go along with a tangy, sweet treat like a blueberry pie. This wine also exhibits some cool chocolaty undertones which bring a welcome complexity to the whole affair. This is one classy dessert experience.

Cherry pie: 2011 Scotto Family Old Vine Zinfandel

To be perfectly fair, this wine basically IS cherry pie in a bottle. You get rich juicy fruit wrapped in a pastry-like oak that does a magnificent job of standing up to the syrupy cherry filling despite being a dry wine. There might not be anything more American than a Zin like this alongside a perfect cherry pie.

Pumpkin pie: 2012 Willowbrook Cellars Pinot Noir

The ultimate Thanksgiving wine meets the ultimate Thanksgiving dessert. This pairing is Autumn in your mouth with tons of warm baking spices underscored by a complex, leaf-pile kind of earthiness that is a classic, telltale sign of superlative American Pinot Noirs.


Item: 88459

750 mL

Retail: $45.00

$29.99 per btl

Product Label.

Willowbrook Cellars Pinot Noir

90 Wine Enthusiast

Item: 89767

750 mL

Retail: $39.99

$17.50 per btl

Product Label.

Scotto Family Old Vine Zinfandel

93 Ultimate Beverage Challeng...

Item: 90079

750 mL

Retail: $19.99

$14.99 per btl

Item: 91097

750 mL

Retail: $28.00

$20.98 per btl